Currently I am working on a difficult dialectic. I've talked about that word before right? The idea of a synthesis between two seemingly opposing polarities/viewpoints. One of those poles is "discipline." I'm not actually sure what exactly the other pole is, something like "have fun now." Maybe "hedonism"? That's kind of got a negative connotation though. Enjoyment in the present, what feels good now.
It came up because of one of my all time favorite hang-ups, a real classic: 'go to bed on time.'
The problem with this is that, when I try and push myself to do it, I often fail, and then feel bad about failing. I fail because, in the moment (say, 8:30 or 9 pm) I decide I don't actually want to go to bed now, I want to stay up doing what I've started doing. I give in to that impulse, enjoy it in the moment, and then curse myself for falling for it again, which leads to not being able to wake up early without incurring a sleep debt. Which is what I really want. I sleep better when I sleep earlier, and I love being awake for the sunrise, and being able to get my daily maintenance behaviors in (meditation, exercise, my morning sit spot) without pushing back the beginning of my work day too late.
This is just one example of this behavior though. I think it kind of boils down to the dichotomy of delayed gratification vs. immediate gratification. Walter Mischel's "marshmallow experiment" and the 'willpower' he discovered is one of the biggest factors in the subsequent success of the five year old children, in all sorts of different areas, from academic achievement, to job success, to relationship satisfaction.
Yet, if I recall correctly, somewhere near the end of the book he talks about how a life devoid of enjoyment in the moment, a life of supreme willpower, could be very sad indeed, with no room left for enjoyment in the moment at all.
The issue I run up against, is something like that. When I try and exert willpower to create a desired long term outcome, not only do I not do it very well (I might be one of the kids who ate the marshmallow right away) but the very act of trying to exert willpower transforms my current experience into something kind of hard and angry and not joyful or playful. However, if I give up and just let my 'enjoy now' self direct things, I begin to feel an existential pain, as pressure slowly builds up about me not being of service to others or having a deeper meaning or purpose to my life. Just a shallow series of pleasant distractions.
So this is the false dichotomy I tend to get stuck in: either wishy-washy just go with the flow and do what feels good, or hard-nosed jaw-clenched constipation-faced straining to do what seems right. It reminds me of the issues I had with classroom management, of either being permissive, or too harsh, neither of which felt good or worked well.
I think I need a third way, something that is disciplined, but without anger or straining. Disciplined with kindness and compassion and flexibility, even as I hold steadily to my values and take the actions that feel right. Disciplined with a sense of play and relaxation and humor and ease.
So that is what I am reaching for, trying to feel out, though it feels like I'm blind and groping in the darkness for a pathway I feel certain must exist.
This is all made exponentially harder by social pressure. I wonder if people who are wishy-washy just seeking pleasure feel social pressure, and it's just me who experiences that as generally socially acceptable, but I don't tend to get push-back when I lean in to that side of the spectrum. However, I definitely get pushback when I lean into the other side, the discipline side. I wonder if this is because we are kind of a materialistic, consumerist culture? Maybe it's our cultural reaction to the puritan work ethic side of things that was ascendant earlier. Maybe it's just the subgroup I tend to live in.
Maybe it's just me, and I grew up with the hedonistic mode as my norm, and when I try to go into discipline mode, it gets noticeably wonkey, because I haven't spent much time around good, non-wonky role models of balanced discipline. And people are just reacting to that.
This very much makes me think of a repeated experience as a new teacher, who didn't know all the rules, starting to work with children, who knew the rules better than I did. Often, they would ask if they could do something, and I could tell, by how they were asking, that they thought they weren't allowed to do it. That cued me in when I otherwise wouldn't know, and I would say to wait until I'd checked in with someone who knew all the rules. Sometimes, it wasn't even a rule, it would have been fine, but because of how they asked, it made me think it somehow wasn't fine and so I ended up saying no.
In that same way, I notice people who have trouble saying no and asserting their boundaries, end up saying no in a way that feels offensive or profoking resistance in others. They are in effect creating a self-fulfilling prophocy, in how they assert boundaries. They think there will be a problem with it, and that makes their delivery cause a problem, wherease someone who felt supreamely comfortable enforcing their boundaries would do so without any of the drama or subtle cues that would provoke negative reactions.
I think I might be doing the same, with trying to be disciplined and enforce those boundaries in social situations. And actually, even just for myself. I think maybe I have an idea of what discipline looks like, and it's not a flattering image, and I'm making it come true.
So yeah, trying to create a different image and follow that.
And I wonder if I'll still get pushback even so? I guess I'll find out. I think I already have somewhat, I think when my behavior makes someone else get less of what they want, there is inevitably some pushback, as with any enforcement of a boundary, but I bet if it is done in a gentle way from that resolution of the dichotomy, it leads to that pushback dying out, rather than growing bigger.
I guess we'll see. I've got to do something though, or the pain of a life lived partially out of alignment with my values and sense of rightness will remain. Experimentation to ensue.
If you are curious where the title of this post comes from: https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/4x6lk8/where_does_the_step_3_step_4_profit_meme_come_from/
Wishing you well in your own search for meaning and resolution of internal conflicts,
Isaac
P.S. also wishing you a good holiday season, and warm time with friends and family and rest and recuperation, like a normal person ;-)
P.P.S. Also resolution of external conflicts, because there are certainly plenty of those in people's lives as well